Is One Word Keeping Your Patent from Being Standard Essential

Case Study June 10, 2024 nan

Determining whether a patent is truly essential to a standard can be a perplexing and complex task. Out of the patents declared as standard essential, the ratio of actually essential patents to declared ones can vary dramatically, ranging from 10% to 80%. This wide variation can be confusing and challenging for companies seeking to navigate the intricate landscape of intellectual property and standards compliance. This is where our expertise comes into play, providing clarity and precision in assessing the essentiality of patents.

The Client’s Dilemma: Assessing the Competition

Our client, an innovation leader in video encoding and decoding technology, faced such a challenge. They needed to determine if a competitor’s patent, US10021393B2, was essential to the published standards, H.265. The patent, held by GE Video Compression LLC, described a sophisticated method of video decoding, focusing on “binarization” of various syntax elements representing for motion vector differences. Our client needed our expertise to verify the standard essentiality of this patent, as it could have significant implications for their own technological and business strategies, such as licensing agreements, development strategies, and market positioning. Thus, the client required a thorough and precise analysis to navigate these potential implications and sought our expertise to verify the claim.

Our Ingenious Solution: Uncovering the Truth

We embarked on a meticulous and multi-faceted approach to analyze US10021393B2. Our process included several key steps: In-Depth Patent Analysis: We began by dissecting the competitor’s patent, focusing on the core claim involving the use of Exp-Golomb coding. According to US10XXXXX3B2, the Exp-Golomb code should function as a suffix following a truncated unary code. We paid close attention to the detailed description of how this coding method was implemented and the specific claims made in the patent.

Standard Examination: Next, we thoroughly examined the ITU-T H.265 standard, particularly the section on motion vector difference coding. This step involved understanding the procedures laid out in the standard specification. We discovered that there are 4 syntax elements of motion vector differences, viz,

We analyzed the sections disclosing the binarization of syntax elements of mvd_coding. Technical Comparison: With detailed insights from both the patent and the standard, we conducted a technical comparison. We realized that the claim requires each binarization of motion vector difference to include an Exp-Golomb code of order 1 as suffix. Note that the word suffix indicates that the Exp-Golomb code of order 1 should be at the end of the binary representation of motion vector differences. However, our findings revealed a crucial difference: the standard placed the Exp-Golomb code in middle of the binary representation,not at the end. Thus, the Exp-Golomb code of order 1 could not be treated as suffix. Because of this discrepancy and the use of the word "suffix" in the claim, the patent could not be classified as a Standard Essential Patent.

Impact: A Revelation of Non-Essentiality

Our detailed and systematic analysis led to a pivotal insight: despite the advanced technology described in US10021393B2, the patent did not align perfectly with the ITU-T H.266 standard due to the placement of the Exp-Golomb code. This single but significant difference meant the patent could not be classified as a Standard Essential Patent. We documented our findings in a comprehensive report, which we presented to our client. The report clearly outlined why the competitor’s patent was non-essential, focusing on the specific technical deviations and their implications. Our explanation was detailed, yet clear, ensuring our client fully understood the reasons behind the non-essentiality conclusion. This revelation had significant implications for our client. Understanding that the competitor’s patent was not essential allowed them to proceed with greater confidence in their strategic planning. It helped them avoid potential legal and financial challenges associated with licensing negotiations and provided clarity on the competitive landscape.

Our Expertise: Ensuring Informed Decisions

Our thorough analysis, precise insights, and dedication to excellence in IP research ensured accurate and reliable findings. By identifying a critical discrepancy in the Exp-Golomb code placement, we provided invaluable guidance for strategic decisions. Our commitment to delivering reliable analyses underscores our role as a trusted partner in navigating IP complexities and standards compliance, reinforcing our reputation for expertise and reliability.

Food for thought

Delve deeper and savor a treasure trove of more such insightful reads


Driving Fuel Efficiency Improvements in the Automotive Industry

Our client from the automotive industry was concerned with reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving fuel efficiency in response to environmental concerns and regulatory mandates. The client had a goal of reducing their carbon emissions by at least 20%, in the next 5 years. Given the transportation sector's substantial role in carbon emissions, exemplified by a rise in global CO2 emissions from transportation by over 250 million metric tons to almost 8 billion metric tons, marking a 3% increase compared to 2021 [1], enhancing fuel efficiency becomes imperative in addressing climate change and fostering sustainability.


Alternative Fuels in the Automotive Industry

Navigating the landscape of sustainable transportation solutions presents multifaceted challenges, particularly regarding the widespread adoption of alternative fuels within the automotive sector. Key barriers include inadequate infrastructure to support alternative fuel vehicles (AFVs), heightened upfront costs, and limited availability compared to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles. Moreover, prevalent concerns such as range anxiety, especially surrounding electric vehicles (EVs) and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles, have impeded consumer confidence and slowed adoption rates. Regulatory inconsistencies further complicate matters, hindering the cohesive framework necessary for progress. Through a strategic approach that encompasses a deep understanding of these challenges and targeted solutions, we aim to facilitate a smoother transition to alternative fuels, contributing to a greener and more sustainable future for the automotive industry.


Maximizing Revenue through Strategic Licensing

Our client, a prominent player in the technology industry, possessed valuable intellectual property (IP) assets but was struggling to maximize their revenue potential. Their existing IP licensing strategy was inefficient, resulting in missed opportunities and underutilized assets. The client sought to improve their revenue generation through strategic licensing.


Streamlining Trademark Search for Brand Protection

A renowned global consumer goods company, one of the industry giants in our portfolio, was strategically planning to extend its product line into new international markets. However, safeguarding their brand from potential infringement and legal disputes posed a significant challenge. The client needed an efficient and exhaustive trademark search solution across multiple jurisdictions.


Resolving Office Actions for a Pharma Company

Our client, a leading pharmaceutical giant, faced a series of intricate office actions that posed a significant threat to the validity of their extensive patent portfolio. It was imperative to respond promptly and effectively to safeguard their intellectual property (IP) rights.


Enhancing Patent Illustrations for a Tech Startup

Our client, a dynamic tech startup, was grappling with a significant challenge related to their patent illustrations. The quality of their existing illustrations fell short, resulting in frequent office rejections. This setback not only hindered their time-to-market but also jeopardized their competitive edge in the industry.


Navigating the Complex World Of SEP

In an era of rapid technological advancements, Standard Essential Patents (SEPs) have become pivotal assets for companies across industries. These patents are essential for complying with industry standards, making them a valuable tool for market leaders. However, managing SEPs presents unique challenges, particularly when it comes to licensing and compliance. Our client, a leading telecommunications company, faced a significant challenge in navigating the complex landscape of SEPs. With a substantial SEP portfolio, they needed a comprehensive strategy for licensing these patents while ensuring compliance with global standards. They sought a partner who could help them:

  • Identify and classify SEPs within their extensive portfolio.
  • Develop a tailored licensing strategy that maximized revenue while fostering innovation and competition.
  • Ensure compliance with international standards and regulations.


Mastering SEP Monetization

In the rapidly evolving world of technology, our client, a prominent electronics manufacturer, found themselves facing a significant challenge. They had identified a crucial component in their products that was essential to industry standards but was also covered by a complex web of Standard Essential Patents (SEPs). Navigating this landscape was becoming increasingly challenging, leading to concerns about potential patent infringement claims and their impact on business operations.

Want to explore more?

Take a look at who we are and what we have to offer.