Discovering Unconventional Prior Art

Case Study October 05, 2023 nan

At Expertlancing, we perform complex prior-art searches daily, but occasionally, we encounter cases that provide truly remarkable experiences and insights. One such case involved an invalidation search for a European patent related to motion vector prediction techniques in the video encoding/decoding domain.

Understanding the Challenge

Our journey began by thoroughly understanding the invention and the associated file history documents to assess the novelty of the claimed invention. Identifying relevant keywords, classifications, and prominent assignees/inventors was our next step. It's worth noting that the terminology used in patents can differ significantly from that in other documents like journals, white papers, or research articles. Thus, compiling a precise set of relevant terms/keywords was crucial.

Crafting the Search Strategy:

Our search strategy started with the use of narrower terms (hyponyms) for a targeted search, followed by synonyms and then broader terms (hypernyms). Our analysis was specifically directed at the novel feature of the independent claim - a decoder calculating a motion vector predictor (MVP) for the current block from the MVP candidates stored in an MVP candidate list buffer, where one MVP candidate is a motion vector of a non-adjacent block, and the non-adjacent block is non-adjacent to the current block of the current picture. We compiled a nomenclature table including synonyms, hypernyms, and hyponyms to guide our search vocabulary. For instance, the keyword "Non-adjacent" was associated with synonyms like non-neighbouring, non-neighboring, non-successive, non-contiguous, non-immediate, farther, remote, and distant.

Thinking Outside the Box

Many patent databases highlight keywords used in search strings. However, in this particular case, the term "non-adjacent" wasn't explicitly highlighted in the results. Our researcher took an unconventional approach by not only reviewing highlighted keywords but also examining figures/images within the references. This unique strategy led to the discovery of a reference mentioning the term "next knight's order" in the context of a chess knight piece move. Although "non-adjacent" wasn't directly mentioned, it was explained in relation to the chess knight's move.

Success and Conclusion

Ultimately, we identified a Category X reference closely aligned with the inventive step and published before the effective filing date of the target patent. This reference disclosed a method for determining the motion vector predictor of the current block using a non-adjacent block. Notably, it introduced a unique term, "Knight's order processing," within a quad row, resembling a chess knight's move, providing spacing between adjacent blocks in the pipeline. In conclusion, prior-art searches are multifaceted challenges, and there is no one-size-fits-all strategy for finding strong results. As IP researchers, it's vital to maintain a broad technological perspective and recognize concepts that might be presented in unconventional ways. Sometimes, the most valuable results are right in front of us, requiring a unique perspective to uncover their significance. At Expertlancing, we've tackled numerous complex prior-art searches across diverse technical domains. We pride ourselves on employing innovative approaches to deliver the best results. If you're seeking inventive solutions to your IP challenges, don't hesitate to reach out to us for more information.

Food for thought

Delve deeper and savor a treasure trove of more such insightful reads


Accelerating IP Monetization for a Startup

A tech startup, had a small but promising IP portfolio. They faced the challenge of monetizing their intellectual property quickly to secure additional funding for research and development. However, with limited resources and expertise, they struggled to identify the most lucrative opportunities within their portfolio.


Resolving Complex IP Litigation

Our client, a prominent player in the healthcare industry, found themselves entangled in a complex patent infringement lawsuit. Their key product was under threat, and their reputation was at stake. With millions of dollars in potential losses hanging in the balance, they needed a swift and effective solution.


Uncovering Killer Prior Art for a 5G Technology Patent

In the dynamic world of 5G technology and Standard Essential Patents (SEPs), we often encounter unique challenges that test our expertise. One such challenge was when we took on an invalidation case related to a 5G technology patent. Our client's goal was clear: find the closest prior art to invalidate a critical patent. The technology at the heart of the patent revolved around "numerology," specifically Subcarrier Spacing. To embark on this prior-art search effectively, understanding the core concept behind the patent was essential. This included grasping key inventors, assignees, critical classifications, and relevant keywords—a crucial step to ensure a productive search.


Navigating the Complex World of Standard Essential Patents

A standard, or a technical standard, in layman’s terms, can relate to fixed norms or requirements to implement or realize a product, process, system, etc. The basic idea behind standards is to maintain consistency throughout the globe when it comes to technical specifications for a particular technology.


Maximizing IP Value through Prior Art Searches

Our Client, a leading technology company, was facing challenges in effectively monetizing their intellectual property (IP) assets. They were unsure about the uniqueness and potential of their inventions. Additionally, they were concerned about potential litigation risks due to insufficient prior art searches.


Maximizing Revenue through Strategic Licensing

Our client, a prominent player in the technology industry, possessed valuable intellectual property (IP) assets but was struggling to maximize their revenue potential. Their existing IP licensing strategy was inefficient, resulting in missed opportunities and underutilized assets. The client sought to improve their revenue generation through strategic licensing.


Transforming IP into Revenue Streams

Our client, a pharmaceutical research firm, had made substantial investments in research and development, which had led to a strong intellectual property portfolio. Nevertheless, they encountered the issue of their IP assets being underutilized and were finding it challenging to fully capitalize on their investments..


Unlocking Value through IP Licensing

Our Client’s corporation, a leading technology innovator, possessed a substantial portfolio of intellectual property (IP) assets. While they recognized the potential value of their IP, they faced a significant challenge in effectively monetizing these assets. Their internal team lacked the specialized expertise required to navigate the complex world of IP licensing, which hindered their ability to maximize the revenue potential of their IP portfolio.

Want to explore more?

Take a look at who we are and what we have to offer.